HTC First to HTC Last


Facebook-hoaxImagine if you were Mark Zuckerberg, the CEO of Facebook, and your product attracted 175 million people on a daily basis.  I don’t know about you, but I would be thinking of other ways to capitalize on this already loyal fan base and try to introduce more products targeted toward their needs without stemming off the confines of what has made Facebook successful.  Hey, what about a cell phone?!

This idea has apparently caught AT&T’s eye when they decided to allow the new Facebook Home software to be integrated in the HTC First cell phone.

Facebook Home is software for your phone that allows Facebook to essentially take over your phone.  This allows users to take advantage of their already established social base on Facebook and communicate with these friends on their cell phone “more conveniently”.  It consists of features such as the cover feed that allows you to glance at your phone for photos and posts, chat heads that allows you to send and receive texts and Facebook messages in one place, allows notifications to be accented on your home screen and an app launcher.

To me, the advantages this product are allowing cell phone users to no longer have to pay a texting fee due to the chat heads feature and from a company point of view it allows Facebook to mass distribute its product without consumers having to buy a cell phone.   However, from a product design standpoint, I don’t think Facebook Home targets the cell phone market very well.  It tries to reinvent the cell phone world too much by focusing the cell phone software design around people instead of apps.  As a consumer would you enjoy having your cell phone constantly flowing with your friend’s pictures and status?htc-first-slide-01

Apparently the majority of Facebook Home users did not enjoy having their phone being constantly engulfed with their friend’s updates when the first month sales reports came back.  “ says that sources at AT&T indicate that fewer than 15,000 of the phones had been sold by the end of its first month.  By comparison, in the three months of the year AT&T sold 6M smart phones, of which about 1 M were android phones- an average of more than 300,000 per month. “AT&T then cut the original $100 price to $99 cents on-contract. The mistake HTC First made to integrate their product with Facebook home has seemed to have left them with an essentially useless product with a lot of inventory.  Now it is rumored that the HTC First will soon be discontinued and unsold inventory will be returned to HTC.

I would question management’s decisions during the product development stages when designing the product, how they reviewed Facebook Homes design, and most importantly how they tested the market.  If these stages were done efficiently I feel that AT&T could have better understood the consumer demand for the HTC First Facebook phone and could have been more aware of this disaster before it occurred.

As a consumer would the HTC First Facebook phone satisfy you?  How do you feel management could have avoided this disaster?



6 thoughts on “HTC First to HTC Last

  1. I can see why the First didn’t do very well. HTC’s earnings last quarter weren’t so hot (again), and to me, the Facebook Home concept is kind of pointless. It’s a good thing that Facebook didn’t doom themselves by making their own phone with their own hardware, but by doing this, they’re bringing HTC down with them. They tried selling the First as a Facebook phone, but I think it’s pretty pointless to call it that when Facebook Home is available on all Android devices, anyway. I tried it just to see what it was all about, hated it, and uninstalled it right away. I also didn’t see the phone being marketed at all, which was probably HTC’s fault considering they are notorious for their lack of advertising.

  2. As a consumer, I did not think the HTC First Facebook phone would satisfy me. I read about the launch a week before it came out and it did not draw any interest in me. I think that having your phone constantly trend your Facebook updates is obnoxious. It seems like I wasn’t the only one that thought so because their sales for the phone and app did not come close to the expected numbers.

  3. I would never buy such a phone as HTC First. I mean I like the idea that you will not have to pay for text messages but then again, I have friends who don’t have Facebook so I would still need that service. I fell that it’s enough that our phones have a Facebook app but to have your whole phone filled with your facebook news feed is a little too much.

  4. This idea seems ridiculous to me. It sounds like the ‘Facebook’ app. Why would anyone want a HTC Facebook phone that takes over all your contacts and such for Facebook? The app can do basically the same thing without taking over the entire phone and design Also I feel as though Facebook is dying down. It will soon be what MySpace has turned into, nothing. Many people are pulling away with it. I think if Facebook wanted to do this, they should’ve done it 5 years ago when Facebook was the new hip thing. Now it just seems like overkill.

  5. The Facbook home had a lot of initial hype, but was blasted by negative reviews after its release. Facebook released the product too soon without getting all the bugs out first. I think it is a good concept, and can provide Facebook with the revenue that they so desperatley need. I personally would not use the product, but I think there are plenty of consumers who would.

  6. I dont understand why facebook would go into such a market. To use facebook as the integral part of a cell phone device clearly was not a well thought out plan by the management team. Besides not just selling cell phones it also affected the facebook company as a whole. I think people look at more things in a phone that gets attention of consumers and thats something both HTC and facebook failed to understand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *